Butterball Turkey Fryers

Dontae Taylor
13 min readJun 10, 2024

--

Get ready to experience the ultimate Thanksgiving feast, as we round up the best Butterball Turkey Fryers on the market! In this article, we’ve handpicked a selection of easy-to-use, innovative, and delicious fryers that will help you whip up a perfect meal. Find out which fryer will stand out from the crowd and turn your Turkey Day into an unforgettable event. Let’s dive in and make your mouth water!

The Top 7 Best Butterball Turkey Fryers

  1. Masterbuilt XL Indoor Butterball Turkey Fryer — The Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer effortlessly accommodates 20lb turkeys, offers convenient drainage, and stands up to commercial standards for a hassle-free frying experience.
  2. Masterbuilt XL 10 Liter Electric Countertop 3-in-1 Fryer, Boiler & Steamer — Healthier Cooking Option — Masterbuilt’s 10-liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler, and Steamer simplifies holiday cooking with healthy design, impressive capacity, and easy cleanup, making it a top choice for frying, boiling, and steaming enthusiasts.
  3. Masterbuilt Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer — Cook up a succulent and juicy turkey or enjoy a variety of flavorsome dishes with the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, featuring 1650W heating power, digital timer, and a space-saving design.
  4. Masterbuilt Propane Turkey Fryer — Perfect for Holiday Feasts — Experience perfect, 18 lb turkey frying with the Masterbuilt Propane Turkey Fryer, featuring a 30-quart pot, patented electronic timer, and easy-to-use design.
  5. Electric Turkey Fryer — 14 lbs. (6.35 Kgs.) Oil Capacity, 1650 Watts 13.75 Amps UPC — Savor the deep-fried delight with the Butterball 20010109 Electric Turkey Fryer, offering a crispy golden finish to your favorite dishes with its 14 lb. oil capacity, convenient design, and perfect frying temperature of 375F (191C).
  6. Healthier Butterball Turkey Fryer for Delicious Meals — Revolutionize your turkey roasting experience with the Masterbuilt 20100809 Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster, delivering a healthier and hassle-free option for creating mouthwatering meals.
  7. Bayou Classic 42 Quart Large Turkey Fryer — Cook your 25-lb Thanksgiving turkey to perfection with the Bayou Classic 4225 42 Quart Grand Gobbler Turkey Fryer, featuring a patented poultry rack and a select-grain leather glove for safe handling.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ we may earn from qualified purchases!

Reviews

Masterbuilt XL Indoor Butterball Turkey Fryer

masterbuilt-butterball-xl-indoor-electric-turkey-fryer-1

I recently tried the Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer by Masterbuilt, and I must say, it was a game-changer for me. This fryer can do way more than just turkey, and it fries with 1/3 less oil than traditional fryers. I have used it to fry turkeys, chicken, fish, hot wings, and even boiled corn on the cob and pasta shells. The built-in drain valve and dishwasher safe components make cleaning a breeze.

One of the features I love the most about this fryer is its quick heating element, which allows you to cook a turkey up to 20 pounds in just four minutes per pound. The analog controls and digital timer with thermostat temperature control make it easy to use, ensuring your food is cooked to perfection.

However, I did notice a few downsides. Sometimes the oil would take longer to heat up, especially when cooking multiple turkeys. It also required a bit of extra planning and time to let the oil recover between cookings. I also found that the fryer did take up a bit of counter space, but I managed to find a spot for it.

Overall, the Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer by Masterbuilt is a fantastic appliance, especially for those who love to fry different foods at home. The convenience and ease of use definitely outweigh the few minor drawbacks.

Masterbuilt XL 10 Liter Electric Countertop 3-in-1 Fryer, Boiler & Steamer — Healthier Cooking Option

masterbuilt-10-liter-xl-electric-fryer-boiler-steamer-1

The Masterbuilt XL 10 Liter Electric Countertop 3 in 1 Fryer, Boiler, and Steamer is a versatile kitchen appliance designed to cater to your family’s holiday dining needs. This extra-large capacity fryer allows you to cook enough food for everyone, including a single 20-pound turkey. Its magnetic breakaway cord ensures safety, while its large basket offers plenty of room for a complete meal.

This efficient cooker requires only a third less oil, making it a healthier choice for frying. With a rotary dial, temperature controls, and a removable heating element, this fryer is convenient and user-friendly. Its built-in drain valve and dishwasher-safe components make cleanup a breeze, while the cool-touch housing keeps things safe.

Overall, the Masterbuilt XL 10 Liter Electric 3 in 1 Fryer, Boiler, and Steamer is a reliable and functional addition to your home kitchen.

Masterbuilt Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer

masterbuilt-butterball-indoor-electric-turkey-fryer-1650-w-silver-1

The Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer is a convenient alternative to traditional oven roasting. Its stainless steel construction and digital timer ensure a crisp, juicy turkey every time.

The powerful heating element can cook up to a 20 lb turkey, and the built-in thermostat temperature control and digital timer promise delicious results. This versatile fryer can also be used to prepare a variety of foods like hot wings, fish, and fries. However, some users may find it smaller than advertised and may need to fry their turkey in multiple batches.

Additionally, the fryer can emit strong odors during cooking, so it is essential to have proper ventilation. With an easy-to-clean design and a wide range of cooking possibilities, the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer may become the centerpiece of your holiday feasts.

Masterbuilt Propane Turkey Fryer — Perfect for Holiday Feasts

masterbuilt-propane-turkey-fryer-1

Introducing the Masterbuilt Propane Turkey Fryer, an impressive appliance that allows you to safely fry or boil your favorite foods. With a capacity to handle up to 18 pounds of turkey, this 30-quart outdoor turkey fryer features a patented electronic timer that effectively prevents overheating.

The device comes equipped with a 30-quart pot, a sturdy steel stand, a durable cast-iron burner, a turkey hanger hook, a lifting hook, and an oil thermometer.

Electric Turkey Fryer — 14 lbs. (6.35 Kgs.) Oil Capacity, 1650 Watts 13.75 Amps UPC

butterball-20010109-electric-turkey-fryer-1

This Butterball turkey fryer is a perfect addition to any kitchen, providing easy and delicious deep-fried goodness for all your favorite meals. Its sturdy, professional design, combined with convenient safety features like a breakaway cord and thermometer, ensures a stress-free cooking experience.

Highlights of this fryer include its impressive 14 lb. oil capacity, convenient 2-gallon frying temperature, and a cooking time of just 375 F, which translates to 3.5 to 4 minutes per lb. for your turkey. The 1650 watts, 13.75 amps power makes it a reliable and efficient choice for your culinary adventures.

One of the standout features of this Butterball turkey fryer is its convenient cooking basket, allowing you to create crispy, delicious deep-fried turkey and numerous other tasty dishes. Whether you want to enjoy perfectly cooked turkey for Thanksgiving, mouth-watering French fries, or perfectly executed onion rings, this fryer delivers outstanding results every time.

Reviews from satisfied customers rave about the ease of use, clean-up, and impressive performance of this turkey fryer. Its compact design and ability to be used indoors make it a versatile choice for any home, while its sturdy construction ensures durability and reliability. So, don’t miss out on the delicious, crispy deep-fried treats this Butterball electric turkey fryer has to offer — give it a try today!

Healthier Butterball Turkey Fryer for Delicious Meals

masterbuilt-20100809-butterball-oil-free-electric-turkey-fryer-and-roaster-1

Picture yourself hosting a flavorful feast this holiday season with the Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster. This clever contraption allows you to enjoy a traditional fried turkey without the mess and fumes typically associated with the old style. Say goodbye to the headache of dealing with peanut oil, gas stoves, and open flames.

One of the many positives of this product is its ease of use. Simply plug it in, wait for it to reach the desired temperature, and let it do its magic. With this compact appliance, you can cook a turkey for Thanksgiving, a potluck, or even a quick family meal without worrying about elaborate preparations.

Despite its convenience, this Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster isn’t without its drawbacks. Some users have reported issues with the roasting ability, claiming that it simply turned out like oven-roasted turkey instead of a deep-fried sensation. The smoke feature is another point of contention, with several customers stating that it didn’t produce the smoky flavor they expected.

However, don’t let these minor drawbacks discourage you from giving this product a try. The Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster may not emulate the deep-fried taste you’re used to, but it can still bring a delicious twist to your traditional Thanksgiving turkey. It may take a bit of trial and error to achieve the results you’re after, but the end product is worth the effort.

In summary, the Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster offers a convenient alternative to the messy, smoky, and time-consuming task of deep-frying a turkey. While it may not perfectly replicate the deep-fried experience, it’s definitely a worthy contender for your holiday roasting needs.

Bayou Classic 42 Quart Large Turkey Fryer

bayou-classic-4225-42-quart-grand-gobbler-turkey-fryer-1

The Bayou Classic 4225, also known as the ‘Grand Gobbler’, is an excellent choice for anyone looking to cook a large Thanksgiving turkey. The 42-quart aluminum stockpot, complete with a vented lid and heavy-duty riveted handles, ensures a smooth and hassle-free cooking experience.

One of the standout features of this turkey fryer is its patented poultry rack and lift hook, designed to create a circular flow of oil around the bird during frying. Combined with the 12-inch fry thermometer and 2-ounce seasoning injector, this turkey fryer allows for precise temperature control and seasoning application.

While it’s recommended for outdoor use, the ‘Grand Gobbler’ can handle even larger turkeys, up to 35 pounds, providing that the legs and wings are removed and fried separately. The 4225 comes with a 1-year limited warranty, and is shipped with a select-grain leather glove to protect your hands from hot oil. Overall, the Bayou Classic 4225 is a top-quality turkey fryer with exceptional features and positive user reviews, earning it a 4.3 rating on the platform.

Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to cooking a turkey, few options are as popular or convenient as a Butterball Turkey Fryer. These innovative appliances allow you to cook a whole bird in a fraction of the time it would take in an oven, resulting in tender, juicy meat that your guests will love. However, with so many different models on the market, it can be challenging to determine which one is right for you. To help make your decision easier, we’ve put together this comprehensive buyer’s guide, outlining the most important features, considerations, and general advice for choosing the perfect Butterball Turkey Fryer.

Types of Butterball Turkey Fryers

Before you begin your search for the perfect Butterball Turkey Fryer, it’s essential to understand the different types available. There are three primary options: tabletop models, stand-alone units, and portable ones. Tabletop models are designed to sit on a countertop or table, while stand-alone units are freestanding and typically larger in size. Portable models are compact and lightweight, making them perfect for those with limited space or who frequently cook turkeys on the go.

Capacity and Size

When choosing a Butterball Turkey Fryer, it’s crucial to consider the size and capacity of the model. Most fryers come in a range of sizes, from small 6-quart models suitable for cooking a single bird to larger 20-quart models capable of handling even the largest turkeys. Make sure to choose a fryer with enough capacity to accommodate your intended bird size, as trying to fit a larger turkey into a smaller fryer can be both dangerous and frustrating.

Safety Features

Safety should always be a top priority when cooking with a Butterball Turkey Fryer. Some features to look for include: an automatic shut-off system that stops the fryer if it becomes too hot or overheated, a locking system to prevent the lid from accidentally being opened while the fryer is in use, and a cool-touch exterior to prevent burns. Be sure to choose a model with these essential safety features to ensure a hassle-free and safe cooking experience.

Price and Warranty

Finally, consider the price and warranty of the Butterball Turkey Fryer you’re interested in. While it may be tempting to choose the most affordable option, remember that higher-priced models may include additional features or better build quality. As for the warranty, many fryers come with a limited warranty that covers defects and malfunctions for a specified period. Make sure you understand the terms of the warranty before making your purchase, and remember that extended warranties are often available for an additional fee.

FAQ

Discover the Features of the Butterball Turkey Fryer

Get ready to tantalize your taste buds with a flavor-packed turkey every time with the Butterball Turkey Fryer. This innovative, easy-to-use appliance is designed to cook a whole turkey quickly and evenly, allowing you to enjoy a delicious feast with your loved ones. Let’s explore the features that make this fryer a must-have for your next holiday gathering:

The Butterball Turkey Fryer boasts a 10-quart capacity, adjustable temperature control, and a digital display that helps ensure a perfect cook every time. With its built-in thermometer, you have peace of mind knowing your turkey will reach the perfect doneness. This fryer is made of durable stainless steel, complete with a removable metal basket and an easy-to-clean cooking pot. Its detachable legs make it a breeze to store, and a clever cord wrap design ensures minimal space is needed when not in use. Say goodbye to dry, overcooked turkey and hello to convenience, versatility, and mouthwatering results.

How Long Does it Take to Cook a Butterball Turkey Fryer?

Cooking times may vary depending on the size of your turkey and your desired level of doneness. On average, a 10–12 pound turkey will take about 3.5 minutes per pound to reach a safe internal temperature of 180°F. Ensure your turkey is thoroughly cooked and avoid overcooking with the use of a food thermometer. Pro tip: make sure your turkey is completely thawed before frying to prevent any accidents or unsafe conditions.

Preparing for turkey fryer success starts with proper preparation. Preheat your fryer to the desired temperature and use a heavy-duty metal basket to lower and remove your turkey. Never handle the turkey or the hot basket with your bare hands to prevent burns or other accidents. As with any appliance, safety first.

How Do I Maintain My Butterball Turkey Fryer?

A little tender loving care goes a long way to keep your Butterball Turkey Fryer in tip-top shape. Be sure to clean and store your fryer properly. After each use, disassemble and clean the components with warm, soapy water and a soft sponge. Avoid abrasive cleaners or harsh chemicals, as they can damage the stainless steel surface.

After cleaning and drying the fryer, store it in a clean, dry location, preferably with a protective cover to shield it from dust and debris. Regularly inspect your fryer for signs of wear or damage, and replace or repair any affected parts promptly. Give your fryer some TLC, and it will reward you with years of delicious meals.

What Kind of Safety Precautions Should I Be Aware Of While Using the Butterball Turkey Fryer?

Frying a turkey is a kitchen adventure best enjoyed with a healthy dose of caution. To avoid any mishaps, follow these safety precautions:

Never leave your fryer unattended while in use. Ensure it’s on a level surface, and the temperature is set according to the instructions provided. Use the heavy-duty metal basket to lower and remove your turkey from the hot oil, and avoid using your hands to handle the hot basket or turkey. Instead, wear oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to protect yourself from burns.

Avoid overfilling your fryer with oil and always thaw your turkey completely to prevent any oil spills, fires, or accidents. Adhering to these guidelines will help make your fryer experience a safe and successful one.

What’s the Deal with the Butterball Turkey Fryer Warranty?

Butterball offers a one-year limited warranty on their Turkey Fryers for any defects in materials or workmanship that may occur during the first year of normal use. If your fryer encounters any issues within the warranty period, Butterball’s customer service is ready to assist you with replacement or repair of the affected components. To ensure you fully benefit from your warranty, register your fryer within 30 days of purchase on the Butterball website, providing your product information and purchase details.

If you have any questions or concerns about your warranty, including coverage or limitations, don’t hesitate to reach out to Butterball’s customer service team for assistance. They’re here to help, ensuring your fryer experience is nothing but delightful.

Can I Make Chicken or Other Birds in the Butterball Turkey Fryer?

Although the Butterball Turkey Fryer is designed with turkey in mind, it’s versatile enough to cook other types of poultry, such as chicken, duck, and geese. Depending on the size of the bird, you may need additional oil and adjust the cooking temperature and time. Remember to practice proper food safety measures, including thawing and cooking your bird to the correct internal temperature using a food thermometer.

With a little creativity, you can use your Butterball Turkey Fryer to fry many types of poultry, ensuring a delicious meal that will impress your guests at your next gathering.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ we may earn from qualified purchases!

--

--